Zadanie 4, matura maj 2023, język angielski dwujęzyczny
Darmowe konto pozwoli wrócić do niego później.
Zadanie
Polecenie
8 punktówRead two texts about photography. Do tasks 4.1.–4.8.
Text 1
CAN PHOTOGRAPHY BE A THREAT TO NATURE?
Nature photography is a wonderful way to share the beauty of the natural world with others who don’t have the opportunity to see a given subject first-hand. An obvious benefit of the genre is that it raises awareness about and generates empathy for endangered flora and fauna. But too much love can be a bad thing if landscapes are trampled and wildlife is frightened – and all because of the compulsion that many people feel to leave their footprint on the world.
The use of photography as a conservation tool dates back as far as photography itself. William Henry Jackson’s photos from his travels to survey the American West convinced the United States Congress to create Yellowstone National Park in 1872. This, in turn, sparked a movement to set aside a number of particularly scenic places as national parks. Ansel Adams carried the torch forward a century later by opening the eyes of millions to the splendour of many western landscapes. More recently, wildlife photographers have got up close and personal with wild animals so that the rest of us can appreciate their beauty while staying out of harm’s way.
But some say there is a dark side to all this exposure of the wild and the natural. In a provocative essay, the activist Bill McKibben argues that the world has enough wildlife photography and that continuing to invade the lives of animal subjects, given the vast superfluity of images already available, is counterproductive in terms of preserving biodiversity. He also decries the distorted view of the world that wildlife photographers portray. “How can whooping cranes be endangered when you’ve seen a thousand images of them – ten times more images than there are actually whooping cranes left in the wild?” he asks.
Most wildlife photographers, myself included, take issue with McKibben’s view, feeling that it is not the number of photographs that matters the most, but rather the fact that wildlife photographers fail to reflect the natural diversity, and instead draw people’s attention to selected “celebrity” species.
And in today’s world, when the average holidaymaker with a digital camera is able to capture their own version of that iconic photo they have seen so many times in magazines, it might be folly to hope people won’t love a spot or a species to death. In the U.S., some national parks have begun to limit the number of visitors at specific photo-friendly spots to make sure that trails don’t get inadvertently widened and native vegetation trampled. Take, for example, the sad plight of the highly elusive nocturnal primates called lorises which live in southern India. The local people cut down trees and use bright lights and scare tactics to capture the animals and enable well-heeled visiting photographers to take the perfect photos of the cute wide-eyed creature. Animals are brought into the village where they are held in captivity for days. Once the shoot is completed, they are usually released far from capture sites and away from their natural habitat, which means that not all of them manage to make it home.
What the nature photographers of the world, amateurs and pros alike, agree on is that they want their subject matter to live on. Being respectful of landscapes and wildlife in the quest to “get the ideal shot” is all that’s needed to keep nature photography from becoming a scourge on the environment.
Adapted from: www.scientificamerican.com
For questions 4.1.–4.4., choose the answer that best matches the text and circle the appropriate letter (A, B, C or D).
4.1. In the second paragraph, the author claims that wildlife photography1 punkt
- Aallowed many scenic places to be protected from the excessive number of tourists.
- Braised awareness that tourists are a threat to animal habitats.
- Ccontributed to spreading the legend of the American West.
- Dgave birth to the idea of protecting places of natural beauty.
4.2. Bill McKibben criticizes wildlife photography on the grounds that1 punkt
- Aphotographers underestimate the scientific importance of some species.
- Bit ignores biodiversity while presenting solely the “celebrity” species.
- Can overabundance of photographs might give a misleading impression.
- Dit disregards restrictions imposed on access to wildlife sanctuaries.
4.3. The example of lorises is used in the text to show that1 punkt
- Anational parks’ infrastructure is often inadequate for photographers.
- Btaking photos in human-created settings can pose a threat to animals’ well-being.
- Cwealthy amateurs may force professionals out of business.
- Dwildlife habitats can be effectively protected from being invaded by humans.
4.4. What is the central claim put forward by the author of the article?1 punkt
- AThe welfare of wildlife should be of primary concern to photographers.
- BProfessional photographers should strive for excellence in their art form.
- CAmateur photographers should focus on species which are on the brink of extinction.
- DWildlife photographers shouldn’t resolve their disputes in public.
Text 2
A PROFESSIONAL PHOTOGRAPHER
“Your work sounds interesting,” Francesca looked across the table at Robert Kincaid. “It is. I like it a lot,” he said. “I like the road, and I like making pictures.”
She noticed he’d said “making” pictures. “You make pictures, not take them?” she asked.
“Yes. At least that’s how I think of it. That’s the difference between Sunday snapshooters and someone who does it for a living. When I’m finished with that bridge we saw today, it won’t look quite like you expect. I’ll have made it into something of my own, by my choice of lens, or camera angle, or general composition, and most likely by some combination of all of those.
National Geographic which I’m currently working for has its own style and demands, but I don’t always conform to the editors’ tastes; in fact, quite often I don’t. And that bothers them, even though they still decide what goes in and what gets left out. I guess they know their readership, but I wish they’d take a few more chances now and then.
That’s the problem with earning a living through an art form. You’re always dealing with markets, which are designed to suit average tastes. That’s where the numbers are. That’s the reality, I guess. But, as I said, it can become pretty confining. They let me keep the shots they don’t use, so at least I have my own private files of stuff that I like. And, once in a while I get the chance to write an article for another magazine on a place I’ve been to, and add some pictures which are too daring for the standards of National Geographic.
One day, I’m going to write an essay called “The Virtues of Amateurism” for all of those people who wish they earned their living in the arts. The market kills more artistic passion than anything else does. Readers want safety, and the magazines and manufacturers provide them with what they want: they give them homogeneity, give them the familiar and comfortable, and they don’t challenge readers in any way. Profit and subscriptions and the rest of that stuff dominate art. Whenever I hear the words ‘market’ or ‘consumers’, I get this grotesque image in my mind of a fat little man in baggy Bermuda shorts, a Hawaiian shirt, and a straw hat with beer-can openers dangling from it, clutching fistfuls of dollars.”
Adapted from The Bridges Of Madison County by Robert James Waller
Based on the text, complete sentences 4.5.–4.8.
4.5. When referring to his work, Robert Kincaid deliberately uses the phrase “making pictures” to draw attention to .1 punkt
4.6. Robert Kincaid thinks that the editors of National Geographic are in their choice of pictures to be published.1 punkt
4.7. Some of Kincaid’s photos which do not make it into National Geographic end up illustrating .1 punkt
4.8. The image of the fat little man with cash in his hands serves Robert Kincaid to exemplify .1 punkt
Korepetytor
Nie wiesz, jak ruszyć? Korepetytor zna to zadanie i poprowadzi Cię krok po kroku, bez gotowca.
5 rozmów · bez karty · Zaloguj się
Sprawdź się
Jak poszło?
Pokaż rozwiązanieUkryj rozwiązanie
Odpowiedź z klucza CKE
4.1. D
4.2. C
4.3. B
4.4. A
4.5. Akceptowane są odpowiedzi wskazujące na: oryginalność/kreatywność; indywidualne/osobiste podejście do robienia zdjęć; różnicę między profesjonalistami a amatorami; artystyczny charakter fotografii.
Odpowiedź oczekiwana: his personal style of taking pictures / the creativity involved in the process of taking photos / the originality of his work
Przykładowe akceptowane odpowiedzi: the process of capturing the view the way he wants it to be; the artist’s contribution to a photograph; the way he treats photography as a form of art; the proffessional technique and tools he is using; the difference between snapshooters and someone who does it for a living; the fact that photography is an art form; the personal aspect of his work; his original style of photography / his individual style; the difference between his work and that of a regular/average photographer; how he treats his work
Przykładowe niepoprawne odpowiedzi: the equipment he uses; the importance of camera; artistic process and mental connection with pictures; the difference of professional and amateur photography; his work; his work put into choosing the right equipment for a photo; the amount of work it takes to make a good photo; the fact that his job requires adjusting the photo to the requirements; pictures to conform editors’ tastes; needs to use his tool to get the best effect; the fact that makes objects into something of his own; process of professional photography; the process of creating a photo; remaking pictures he had taken; differences between photographers; the fact that he does it for a living; the process taking place before taking the picture; his special technique; the fact that his work is extraordinary
4.6. Akceptowane są odpowiedzi, które wskazują na (bardzo/zbyt) zachowawcze / niewystarczająco odważne podejście wydawców.
Odpowiedź oczekiwana: too conservative / too selective / not open-minded enough
Przykładowe akceptowane odpowiedzi: too concerned about readers; too focussed on readership/numbers; not daring enough; not too flexible; not willing to experiment; excessively picky; not taking enough risk/chances; very restrictive; not open-minded enough; too narrow minded; really/quite cautious; strictly sticking to their style; too concerned about their readers
Przykładowe niepoprawne odpowiedzi: not professional; considerate towards the readers; not right / often mistaken; short-sighted; too conserving; very specific; average and safe; sometimes tasteless; too safe; homogenous; confining; greatly demanding; tasteless and predictable; strict; too close minded; the safe opinions
4.7. Akceptowane są odpowiedzi wskazujące na artykuły zamieszczane w innych czasopismach lub inne czasopisma/publikacje.
Odpowiedź oczekiwana: articles for other magazines
Przykładowe akceptowane odpowiedzi: other magazines / other articles / other publications; articles for other publishers; the articles he writes for other magazines; other magazines to which he writes articles; an article for another magazine
Przykładowe niepoprawne odpowiedzi: his own collection / private files; being featured in other magazines; his articles on a place he’s visited; in the article for another magazine; other publishers; articles in other publishers; the places he visited in a more daring way; the articles he writes for another magazines; things Kincaid himself likes; articles he writes for magazines; another magazine pages
4.8. Akceptowane są odpowiedzi pasujące do występującego przed luką exemplify, w których zdający wskazuje na: negatywny stosunek bohatera do opisywanego zjawiska; typowych czytelników gazet; komercjalizację sztuki / dominację pieniędzy nad sztuką; oczekiwania rynku / odbiorców rynku medialnego.
Odpowiedź oczekiwana: typical magazine reader / the commercialization of art / his aversion towards mindless consumerism
Przykładowe akceptowane odpowiedzi: average NG reader; the grotesque nature of conforming to marketing and consumerism; the domination of profit and subscriptions in art; that the art is dominated by profit and market; his negative attitude to consumerism dominating art; the fact that market kills art; the problem of market killing art and artistic passion; the condition of art market that only wants to suit the customers’ expectations; the problem with money being more important than art; the consumer of mainstream media he is working for; how he perceives market and consumers; the typical consumer; how he sees a basic consumer; his view of the market and consumers; how he sees an average consumer in the market; his view on market and consumerism; what he thinks of when he hears “market” and “consumers”
Przykładowe niepoprawne odpowiedzi: homogeniety and safety of what magazines show; killing artistic passion; the state of art market nowadays; homogenity and comfort that manufactures provide; his anger and disappointment of consumers; his hate for the market; how profit of the market dominates the art; what market demands; profits dominate over art; the profit-oriented art-industry; what a typical profit driven person looks like; market’s impact on people; the aim of the manufacture; artists depending on markets and consumers; how the market controls the work of artists; his idea of the contemporary art market; words “consumers” and “market”; how the market profits amateurs; people associated with the market that are greedy and want to maximize profits; his view of people who only consider art in terms of profit
W 4.5.–4.8. akceptowane są wszystkie odpowiedzi nieujęte w zasadach oceniania, które są merytorycznie poprawne i spełniają wszystkie warunki zadania.
Schemat punktowania
Za każde z zadań 4.1.–4.8.:
poprawna odpowiedź.
odpowiedź niepoprawna albo brak odpowiedzi.
Komentarz. Do 4.5. akceptuje się odpowiedzi wskazujące na: oryginalność/kreatywność, indywidualne/osobiste podejście do robienia zdjęć, różnicę między profesjonalistami a amatorami, artystyczny charakter fotografii. Do 4.6. akceptuje się odpowiedzi wskazujące na bardzo/zbyt zachowawcze/niewystarczająco odważne podejście wydawców. Do 4.7. akceptuje się odpowiedzi wskazujące na artykuły zamieszczane w innych czasopismach lub inne czasopisma/publikacje. Do 4.8. akceptuje się odpowiedzi pasujące do occurring przed luką exemplify, wskazujące na: negatywny stosunek bohatera do opisywanego zjawiska, typowych czytelników gazet, komercjalizację sztuki/dominację pieniędzy nad sztuką, oczekiwania rynku/odbiorców rynku medialnego.